Showing posts with label Research Tips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research Tips. Show all posts

Friday, October 23, 2026

Serious Genealogical Research and AI - Are they Compatible?


I remember being skeptical when DNA first became popular as a genealogical tool, and I admit I was skeptical when AI was being suggested as a new genealogical tool.


Because there are so many unresearched and casual family histories posted on the Internet, I wondered if there was any way I could find AI helpful in my research?

I decided to put AI to the test on my 5th great grandparents, John and Sophia Yerkey, who have been a brick wall for years. I had acquired many Ancestry DNA matches on that line, but with 150 years of West Virginia ancestors and many family marriages among cousins and siblings, those matches could have happened anytime in history. So unfortunately, DNA wasn't producing any helpful clues.


Sophia was my continuous direct maternal ancestor through my mother, my maternal grandmother, my maternal great grandmother etc. to my 5th direct maternal great grandmother. Hoping to find something on her history, I did the mtDNA test which uses the direct maternal line, somewhat similar to the male y-DNA test. I came up empty handed as far as any genealogical help. My matches only had traced their ancestors to more recent relatives, born long after mine. So, I still had questions about both John and his wife Sophia born in the mid 1700's.


Over the years I had collected a few clues about John, my 5th great grandfather. He was easier to research since we can follow males through deeds, tax lists, census records. I had practically nothing at all on his wife, only the dates of their children's birth and that the children were born in Maryland. From 1791 when the family arrived in what became Harrison County, West Virginia, I had a fairly complete continuing history but nothing about their Maryland history or their ancestors.


What kept me interested in this line was the possibility that John was a Hessian soldier and was captured at the Battle of Trenton. The possibility of John Yerkey being a Hessian soldier was in a write-up by Leo F. King published on 26 November 1935 in "The Telegram" a Clarksburg, (Harrison county) WV newspaper. The writer stated "John Yerkey settled west of McConkey, about two miles from Good Hope. Yerkey was a Hessian soldier and was captured at the battle of Trenton by John Patton, who settled about two miles southwest of Good Hope on lands now owned by Leeman Maxwell. John Patton served under George Washington in the Revolutionary war and is said to have crossed the Delaware with Washington." Because this was a simple narrative about settlement in the area and not a family history as such, I felt this information was fairly believable. I was also able to find that John's descendants had continued to live in the area so I could make the connection and consider this might be an important clue.


I continued to gather and save data as I ran across it in researching other ancestors who lived in the area, but I figured if John was born in Germany, it might be a dead end search for him.

This week, I decided to put AI to the test. At first I got typical "Internet" answers, but as I added maps, history and documents, the answers became more specific. AI was even able to translate some documents from a Maryland Lutheran church, written in German. Language was not a barrier for AI. AI went to places I had not gone and filled in some blanks and answered several questions I had. Finally, it pulled together a timeline showing me what was believable and probably accurate, as well as pointing out some problems such as the Americanization of names. I feel really confident now of the marriage in Maryland of John and Sophia and that the births of their children is accurate. Also AI gave me a continuous history of the locations of Hessian prisoners after their capture. One problem I had was that the John Patton in the story did not seem to match quite right with a John Patton responsible for the prisoners in the war. AI pointed out their were 2 men, one was higher ranking and probably in charge while the other John Patton was a private. However, that John had a responsibility guarding prisoners and would have been more likely to form a friendship and have brought John Yerkey to Harrison County.


I am sharing my AI experience because I was surprised to find it was far more helpful that I had guessed it would be. So, like DNA, I now plan to put it in my genealogical "tool box".

Give it a try?

Friday, July 22, 2022

 

A Person Convinced against their Will is of the Same Opinion Still!

 

We have all known people who refuse to change their minds no matter how much proof you supply, and this is especially frustrating in genealogy.  No matter how much careful research you have done; no matter what the DNA test reports; no matter how much objective proof you provide, some non-believers cannot be convinced.

I have spent years trying to bring documentation and DNA to prove family lines, hoping to answer questions and "set the record straight".  But time after time, I have encountered people who want to "fight" the evidence.  It's like being a prosecutor in a court case with strong evidence, but the jury is still not convinced.

While researching and questioning his line, my husband was told "It doesn't matter who you claim as your ancestor unless the are trying to join the SAR (Sons of the American Revolution)".   That organization and the DAR (Daughters of the American Revolution) have increased their standards of proof.  They no longer allow family histories, for example, as evidence.  Now one must have documentary evidence of a direct relationship in order to join.  Other than those organization requirements and professional genealogists, does anyone really care who you claim as an ancestor? 

Many people want a royal or a military ancestor in their history, and when they think they have one, they don't want to relinquish him or her.  

What do I do?  Much less than I used to do.  Am I giving up?  Perhaps.  

I have decided not to be a genealogical policeman, trying to "arrest" those folks who are willing to accept information without evidence to prove or disprove it.  Instead, I am concentrating on gathering evidence through documents and DNA to convince myself that my ancestors are truly my ancestors. 




  

Saturday, July 24, 2021

 Where Do You Find Free Genealogical Records?




An Ancestry member asked me where she could find additional records online. As you probably know, Ancestry owns two other genealogical sites that require payment - Newspapers and Fold 3.

The appeal of paying and using Ancestry is the millions of family trees, the documents and the DNA matches. The Fold 3 site contains military records for the various wars, and the Newspaper site has many publications, and both have a way to link the information back to your family tree at Ancestry.

However, if you don't want to pay, there are many sites that offer much of what Ancestry and its sites offer - at no charge.

Find-A-Grave is owned by Ancestry but is still free. Since all the information has been added by volunteers, I would hope they never decide to charge. https://www.findagrave.com/

WikiTree https://www.wikitree.com/ and Family Search (LDS site) https://www.familysearch.org/en/ offer the ability to create and share online trees. You must register but there is no charge. The problem with those trees is that they are shared and others can modify. Ancestry allows you to invite others to edit your trees, but you have control over those people and how much you allow them to participate.

But you can use what Family Search has to offer without creating a tree there. FamilySearch has many documents online. The personal trees there that people have added are full of errors, but the documents are helpful and some of them are not on Ancestry.

If you have Ancestors from West Virginia, for example, there is a great site with birth, marriage and death records: http://www.wvculture.org/vrr/va_select.aspx 

Other states have similar online records to search. You can often find tax, birth, death and marriage records. Here's a link to the Missouri site which has 9 million records. https://www.sos.mo.gov/mdh/  And there are many other states that offer vital records online.

The National Archives site has newspapers and many other records. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/.../free-online.../...

Another overlooked resource is to search in Google Books: https://books.google.com/ Some are not available because of copyrights but there are many available there. When searching narrow your search by adding "history" or "genealogy" and then be specific with names, dates or locations. I have found many family histories this way.

Another site filled with books on genealogy is Genealogy Gophers https://www.gengophers.com/#/. This is a free site, and you can view or download a minimum number books. They ask for a donation after 3 downloads. The site is worth a donation.

Saturday, June 19, 2021

Beware of False Genealogies and Genealogists

                                                              Beware!

I became a witness to a "war" between a person who writes books about one of my ancestral lines and others who felt they had become her "target".  I was only an observer, and I was skeptical when people warned me against contacting her or using her findings.  After all, she claimed to be a "genealogist" and  her "documents" were on Ancestry.  I looked at her biography on line, and her credentials seemed to be fine. 

But  I kept encountering researchers who were warning me off and even seemed paranoid about this woman.  I thought that was a bit strange, and I wondered about them.  Were they jealous or had something against her?  I was beginning to feel she was being bullied by people.

As I compared information about our common line, I noticed that what I had researched didn't match her family stories and her documents.  That didn't bother me too much, since genealogy is not an exact science.  However, in most cases people acknowledge if they have taken liberties or explain their conclusions.  She didn't, but I excused her since many mistakes are out there, and genealogy is generally just a hobby.

When I found she had published several books about our shared family line, I dug deeper into her "research". After a while, I began to wonder why she never reported the sources of her "documents" and why the handwriting on the documents she shared seemed so modern?   Although she claimed she was reporting researched family history, her books seemed to be "historical fiction".  

I later learned that she has threatened law suits against people who challenge her work, that she has changed other people's work online and publicly called out people who disagree with her.   Needless to say I was a bit shocked to find out she apparently was as mean-spirited as people claimed.  Wow!  

The following is a portion of a letter written in defense of one of the person's victims. This letter was written by a researcher who had been attacked by the person mentioned above and described her experiences.

"(The author) contacted me the first time probably in 2011 after reading a message that I had written on Rootsweb or one of the other message boards. At this time, I think she was writing her first book. She asked me to send her a copy of my documentation, she wanted to include it in her book. I shared some information, but did not send all my documentation.  Two years later, (I was asked) to join the (family research) Group on Facebook. I joined for a short time, but I found (her) to be overbearing and quickly dropped out of the group. She started harassing me through emails, threatening to sue me for defamation of (her ancestor's) character.  I had to block her three times on my email account, because she kept changing her username to reach me. She was also harassing me on Find-A-Grave and Ancestry. Find-A-Grave removed her from their site. I do not know for certain that Ancestry contacted her, but after numerous complaints by me about her, the harassment stopped or so I thought. In Oct 2016, she contacted almost all of the teachers at my school hoping that someone would email her a negative comment. I had to ask school officials to block her from our school email site. After the book was written I thought she was through, but this week she deleted information on WeRelate.org and also recently set up a duplicate account on Find- A Grave.  (She) likes to cut and paste. She takes comments and changes the context to make it look like people are agreeing with her. (She) has placed documentation on Ancestry that a descendant submitted DNA and proved (his ancestry) but the ancestor never married and does not have any descendants.  Before she wrote her book, she was told numerous times by several people that her documentation was wrong, but she wrote the book anyway. Then all the records were placed on Ancestry and people began posting them to their trees."

All of this reminded me of a woman who sold fraudulent genealogies in my Dotson line to help people join the Daughters of the American Revolution. She is the reason that a Sarah Hollyday is still showing up erroneously as a wife of my Richard Dotson, and may always show up as a wife.   It was only when a book was being written about Richard Dotson that the truth came out.  The wife of the author was the county librarian and secured the book which supposedly "documented" the "marriage" of Sarah to Richard.  The book existed, and the pages referenced existed, but the information showed she married another person and was never married to Richard Dotson.  Unfortunately, some want to make money from family history and will create history if it's not available.  

Beware of the bearer of genealogical gifts that seem too good to be true, and beware of challenging the bearer of the "gifts" if money is the motive.

Monday, May 3, 2021

How Do you Prove your Ancestry?

Some Notes from 

https://bcgcertification.org/skillbuilding-evidence-revisited-dna-poe-and-gps/

A lineage, pedigree, or genealogy is a series of related assertions proved by a complex web of interwoven evidence. In weaving that web, we cite our sources and, when necessary for clarity, explain our evidence. We may have inadvertently chosen faulty materials or made a mistaken connection, but our goal is a portrait of the family that is as close to the true picture as possible.

Evidence is drawn from information in written records, oral testimony, and artifacts. Information is inert and impartial, until we use it to support an assertion about someone’s identity, relationship, biographical event, or circumstance. There are, of course, no “irrefutable” sources. Even a birth certificate may be mistaken in some of its details.

We measure the power of evidence—its convincing weight—by asking of it the following questions::

Are these sources generally accepted as reliable? 

Is the information itself coherent and free of obvious error? 

Was the data’s significance understood? 

Were its logical, physiological, psychological, social, legal, religious, ethnic, and historical contexts accurately reflected in the evidentiary conclusion?

Is the data being used as direct or indirect (circumstantial) evidence? 

Proof

Proof is dependent on the sum of our evidence. No single item, regardless of how reliable, well-interpreted, or direct, can stand alone in support of an assertion about a specific person.

Whatever the content of a genealogical statement, when we correlate and assemble a body of evidence in its support, we build a case for its validity.

Judgment about a proof’s power to convince depends on answers to another set of questions:

Was the search for relevant information thorough? 

Did it include all sources that a reasonably knowledgeable genealogist would expect of a competent search?

Is the evidence valid? 

Was the evidence assembled correctly? 

Does all the underlying data concern the same person, event, or relationship? Has it been faithfully portrayed, without distortion or significant omission?

Does the proof satisfactorily answer questions raised by (a) data that conflicts with the genealogical statement; and/or (b) information that might have been available in records that were never created or have been subsequently destroyed.

If the answers to these questions warrant our conviction that the statement is substantially true, it is said to be proved. That does not mean that it can never be disproved by additional data or more precise interpretation. It does mean that frivolous challenges, such as “but something else could have happened” or “The History of the M. Family (undocumented) says otherwise,” should not be viewed as sufficiently powerful to destroy our case.

Friday, August 21, 2020

How to Document your Family History

 Sources of Documentation


After we gather basic information about our immediate family and ancestors, how and where do we find "proof" to document our findings? 


For about 100 years, most states and counties have required that certain Life events be recorded or registered, such as births, marriages, divorces and deaths.  Official records may not exist before there were laws requiring registration.

Birth

Once birth registrations were required by states, birth certificates became excellent sources.  Records can provide more than just a name, date and place of birth.  Other information may include the father's name, mother's maiden name, birth order (how many prior children), birth locations of parents, occupation of parents, who reported the birth, who attended the birth (doctor or midwife) and other information. Sometimes people have filed "delayed" birth certificates.  These give basic information and also show the documentation used to verify the birth, such as people with relationships or official documents.  Family Bibles can be a source of birth records, and if recorded by a parent, are likely to be accurate.  A birth announcement or a newspaper record of a birth is likely to be accurate .  Draft registrations and marriage records often show the date of birth, but these may be off for a year or so if the person wanted to be older or younger to marry or join the military.  Court documents often record the age, but not the date of birth.  Tombstones are often inaccurate or show only a year of birth. Census reports show a person was alive or died during a census year, but often only an approximate age.  Ages are often estimated by those giving the information to the census taker. Other documents may list age or even birth dates. Again, the best sources are those that were prepared when the living person was giving information.  

Marriage

Even in colonial times, marriage licenses or bonds were required and certain licensed persons, primarily ministers, could perform legal marriages.  Some early court, church and ministerial records still exist, but many have been lost or destroyed.  In early days, ministers were required to report the marriages to the county clerks, but often they simply provided a list of the marriages performed and only showing the names of the parties and the date of the marriage.  Bonds were required for licenses, and if one of the parties was under age, then permission had to be granted by a parent or guardian.  Often it is the bonds that provide the most information about the bride and groom. The bondsmen were usually the groom and a relative of the bride. Family Bibles, obituaries and newspaper reports can be other sources for marriages.  Common law marriages have been treated differently in different states over the years. A misconception is that if people live together for a certain length of time that alone constitutes a legal common-law marriage. This is not true anywhere in the United States. Some states will still legalize common law marriages, but each state has specific requirements.  Some states, such as West Virginia, have never recognized "common law" marriages as legal while other states, recognize a common law marriage if it was registered before a certain date, and met certain requirements, but no longer honor them as legal if they were not registered by that date. 

Death

Most death certificates in the past 100 years or so are very complete, including information such as the exact date and time of death; the location of the death; where the person was residing just before death; parents' names and their places of birth; marital status and name of spouse; cause or causes of death; name of undertaker and location of burial.  Military records, particularly if a person was receiving a pension, usually contain at least the date of death and often names of dependents if they became eligible as beneficiaries.  Family Bibles can be a source.  Tombstones may be helpful.  Since many stones were prepared long after death, they may not be as reliable. Clues as to where to look might be found in recent records just before the person died.  For example if a person was living in Pittsburgh, PA in the 1920 census and died in 1921, that area would be a starting place to search.   

Family Stories and Biographies

These stories rarely have documentation, but there are often clues suggesting names and locations and where to look further.  Also, quite often in telling the story of a person's life, the names of spouses, parents, children and siblings are reported, as well as different locations where the families lived. 

Land and Tax Records

Although these records will not give vital statistics, they may establish relationships as well as locations where your ancestor might have lived. Some older deeds may be more complete since deeds were not always immediately recorded, and the "trail" of ownership may be outlined in the deed itself.  I was able to find proof of relationships when a deed indicated that the son received land which his father had inherited from his father, and they were named. If an ancestor appears in tax records for several years in a particular county, that suggests settlement, although not always since he might be an absentee owner.  Sometimes that information is indicated.  Tax collectors sometimes recorded the day and month that taxes were collected.  The assumption is that those taxes collected on a given day were people who lived in the same area, so the near neighbors might offer clues.  

History and Maps

Familiarity with locations and history of an area can give you confidence that the information you gathered is valid.  In the early days of the country, settlement was first along the Atlantic coastal areas in the 13 original colonies.  Eastern Pennsylvania and eastern Virginia counties were organized in the 1600's while western counties were organized in the early to mid 1700's.  As settlement grew, counties continued to split into newer counties.  Post Revolutionary War, western settlement in those states and border states increased rapidly.  Dates and maps can help you understand that ancestors may have lived in 2 or 3 counties or states while not relocating.  Records were supposed to follow the county and state changes, but that did not always happen. There were also "border wars".  An example is the southwestern Pennsylvania - Virginia land claims.  Virginia claimed the same land in their West Augusta county that was being claimed by Pennsylvania in their Westmoreland county.  This controversy was finally settled when the Mason-Dixon survey was completed.  West Virginia is unique in that it was part of Virginia until mid Civil War (1863) when a convention was formed to create the new state. Normally this can only be done by the United States Congress.  So the same counties that show Virginia before 1863 are showing West Virginia post 1863.  Records of marriage, for example, can be showing in both states.  Eastern Tennessee was part of North Carolina until the state was formed; Kentucky was part of Virginia.  In fact, Virginia Revolutionary War soldiers were granted parts of Kentucky as payment for their service.  Ohio and other states were part of the Northwest Territory and only became states after 1800.   So, if your ancestor was born in "Kentucky" in 1780, he was actually born in Virginia.  So, be aware of those dates and where records might be located. 


Thursday, August 13, 2020

What to Believe or Disbelieve?

 Who and What should I Believe?


Mark Twain popularized the saying "There are three kinds of lies - lies, damned lies, and statistics."  

That phrase can describe the journey of a family researcher.  At first we think that everything we find is of equal value - family stories, public records, tombstones, census reports, vital statistics, family Bibles, documents, books, and military records.  

When we compare our findings, we wonder how could someone have been born in different years in different places and died in different years in different places? Why does the mother's name on a death record not match the name on the birth record?  Why is the death in one state and the burial in another?  How much confidence can we place in information we find?  How do we draw conclusions when details don't match? Do we give up or dig deeper?

I was part of a group of researchers who discussed what was the most reliable source of information.  The conclusion was that information is most reliable when recorded while the person was living, and more specifically, when the person himself gave the information.  Two examples are applications for pensions for military service and draft registrations.  Pension applications were taken in court, and the applicant swore to the information.  Draft registrations were recorded by others, but in World War I and II registrations, the person had to sign.  Those are only two examples.  Others could be a marriage or divorce records - any document where the person was present and signing to the veracity of the information in the document.

We concluded that the least reliable information is information recorded many years after the death of the person - the more time that has passed, the less reliable the information.  This would include family books and stories written or told years after the events. Other documents produced others while a person was alive can be helpful, but who was interviewed and how likely they would have correct information should be considered?  For example a parent should know the correct birth date for their child, even years later.  


Census Reports

Federal census records are completed every 10 years and report who was living in a household on April 1st. The documents show the name of the census taker and a date, but not who was interviewed to gather the family information.  Was it the second wife who was estimating her husband's date of birth and guessing at where he was born?   Until 1850, census reports only showed the names of the head of the household with the only sex and age ranges of others in the home.  Each census report from 1790 to 1940 gathered different kinds of information.  Reports are not released to the general public until 72 years after the year taken. The 1940 census report is available, but the 1950 census will not be released until April 2022.  Although the first federal census was reported in 1790, the Virginia list was destroyed, and most of the 1800 list is missing. If you see a 1790 census for Virginia, remember that it was reconstructed from tax lists of the mid 1780's.  By 1790, your Virginia ancestors may have moved on to another location.   

Tax Lists

Old tax lists can be helpful to establish locations and dates. With changing county and even state lines and people with similar names, one must be careful in drawing conclusions. The old tax lists show only the head of the household and males who are over age 16.  In colonial days these lists were also used to show who were old enough to be in the militia. 

Colonial Records

Even before the United States of America became a country, the 13 colonies had established governments.  Counties were created, officials were elected or appointed, militias were formed and taxes were collected.  Some of these old records still exist and can contain a picture of our ancestors' lives, if we can establish the time and location they lived. Some churches, especially the Quakers, kept detailed records of births, marriages and deaths. Quakers used a different calendar, starting their year in March.  So if you see a record showing the 8th month, it would be our October, not August.  Also, in the early 1700's the type of calendar was changed, so you may see a date recorded as 1745/46 referring to the year under the old and new calendars.

Public Records and Official Documents

Some documents have been digitized and are published on-line, but many are retained in court houses or state archives or national archives.  When we visited the state library in Virginia, the librarian said only about 10 per cent of their records had been digitized.  When we visited a remote court house in West Virginia, we found the only known record of my ancestor's marriage in a file.  We were fortunate to be able to take a digital photo which I've been able to share with others.  Depending on how much information you want to obtain, you may have to request and pay for copies of official records that do not appear online.  Also until the 1900's most states did not require counties to report vital statistics to the state, so you may only find an old record in county court house records.

Maybe I shouldn't be surprised, but I have found many mistakes on "official" records.  My great grandfather's death certificate is an example. When his father died, my grandfather provided information for his death certificate.  He gave the correct name for his father's father (his grandfather), but he reported his father's mother (his grandmother) with the name of his great grandmother, rather than his grandmother.  This puzzled me for years until I finally figured it out.  But it will always be in the "official" records. The second case was when my grandfather married his second wife.  He gave the information to the clerk to issue the marriage license.  The first question was apparently who were his parents, which he reported accurately.  Then the clerk must have asked who were "her" parents.  Misunderstanding, he reported the names of his own mother's parents, rather than the bride's parents.  And that too is now the "official" record.  

More recently when my father died, we were anxious to get the death certificate to settle his affairs.  When received, we noticed two mistakes, so we asked that they both be corrected and the certificate reissued.  We finally received a copy, but with only one correction - with the mistake of the wrong cemetery still on the "official" record.  We knew the information was wrong but went ahead and used the certificate to take care of business.  We have a photo on Find-A-Grave of his tombstone in the correct cemetery, but the "official" record is still wrong.  

Tombstones

Tombstone information can be helpful, but again, since they were placed after death, they may contain errors.  There was an error on the stone for my grandfather, showing the wrong year of his birth.  The stone was beginning to show wear and tear. In a gesture of goodwill and as a surprise, one of his descendants ordered and placed a new stone, sending photos to the family.  You guessed it, the new stone also has the wrong year of birth.  Find-A-Grave is a great site for finding photos of stones, but people have also added "best guesses" as to parents and dates for stones that cannot be found. If there is no photo or the information makes no sense, use with caution.  

Military Records

These are usually accurate, but there were always people who shared the same name, even unusual names.  Unless you have more information than a name, you may find your ancestor belongs to someone else.  I have seen many cases of people wanting to claim a Revolutionary War ancestor but who have claimed the wrong person.  Yes, the person was in the Revolutionary War, but he was not their ancestor. I have spent a lot of time exploring the Dotson and Dodson lines in America.  To date, I have only located one Thomas Dodson who was a documented Revolutionary War soldier. However, I have found the same man claimed as an ancestor for at least 3 different Dodson or Dotson lines.  There are military record sites, such as Fold 3, which charge to view copies of some muster rolls and payrolls for soldiers.  These records may help track where your ancestor served during the war. The site also has copies of Revolutionary War pension applications.  For southern Revolutionary War soldiers, there is an excellent free site where many pension applications have been transcribed.  

Family Bibles

The key to accuracy may be when the information was recorded. Ideally, you will have a copy of the title page showing when and where the Bible was printed and hopefully predating the information recorded in the Bible. I have a copy of one Bible where the father recorded all the birth information for his children born in the late 1700's and the deaths for any who died while he was living.  I feel that this information is more accurate than any of the other information I have found about his children.  However, if someone creates the data much later, it may or may not be correct.  Also, beware of digital copies that people say are from "the original".  I know of one case where a person wanted to "prove" her ancestor, so she copied names and information into a Bible with dates in the 1700's and 1800's.  Her mistake was that the names were printed.  I have never seen any type of handwriting other than cursive in those early years.  Even if her Bible is valid, I would still have doubts without other documentation.

Family Stories and Books

When were the stories told or the books written?  The problem with a book is that people want to believe it is accurate.  Even if the information is later disproved, the misinformation stays in print.  A book on the Dodson line was published in 1908 by a minister.  He did not document his sources, but he outlined English ancestors for the American line in the beginning of his book.  It was not until 100 years later that researchers went to England and discovered that his information was incorrect.  The people he said came to America instead lived, married and died in England.  However, people still quote that book as a source and probably always will.

Lies

Most of us know of a "family lie" such as a grandmother being passed off as a mother to cover up an illegitimate birth by her daughter.  Often the grandparents raised a child, and sometimes the child knew or did not know the truth.  I have seen one case where the obituary continued the myth by reporting the real mother as a sister and the grandparents as the parents.  Sometimes people lied about their ages to join the military or to pretend to be of legal age to marry. Divorces carried a social stigma, required legal charges and could be expensive. I have seen many census reports where people are listed as widows while their spouse is still living. They may or may not have ever divorced but they weren't widowed.Sometimes both parties remarry but continue to report they were widowed on the "official records". Sometimes people changed their names to hide their pasts or because they were "running from the law". 

DNA testing is now revealing some of those lies and cover ups. Researchers are now facing how, when, where and if they should report the truth. 

Saturday, August 8, 2020

Names and the Many Variations



Names are Special


From birth until death we are identified by names given to us by others. We may share the name of a relative, acquire a nickname, be called by our middle name or be known by our married names. But we continue to be identified throughout life with the surname given to us early in our lives.

Shakespeare wrote, "A rose by any other name would smell as sweet". The phrase suggests that what we call a person is of little significance, and that a name doesn't change the character of a person. But to each of us, our surnames are special and speak to our own personal family lineage and history. Our surnames contain the seeds of our unique family trees and will be imparted to future generations.

However, surnames did not always exist. Because populations were small and people knew their neighbors, given names were sufficient. But as populations grew, people needed more specific identities such as Big James or Little James or John's son or Dod's son. Sons eventually would be called by a combination of their given name, coupled with their new surnames, such as James Johnson or Richard Dodson, and following generations would carry on that surname.

I am using my birth name of Dotson to illustrate the challenge.

Historically, Dodsons and Dotsons can be found in the British Isles, but in very early American records, we only find the surname Dodson. In later years we find the spelling of some of those Dodsons changed by accident or design to Dotson. It is not unusual to find both spellings recorded at different times referring to the same person, Whether the changes in spelling were intentional or transcription errors is unknown, and it would be a mistake to assume that the spelling of the name confirms a person was or wasn't your ancestor.

Were my ancestors Dodsons or Dotsons? Perhaps they were both.

In Pennsylvania, the Dodson spelling has prevailed into modern days with Dodsons in both eastern and western Pennsylvania. Occasionally Dotsons are found among families who migrated from Pennsylvania, but in general, the Dodson spelling remains in Pennsylvania.

The descendants of the Charles Dodson line of Farnham Parish in Richmond County, Virginia,were also likely to retain the Dodson spelling of the name for several generations, but not always.

The Dodsons from the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia were more likely to become Dotsons as they migrated into other parts of the country. We find both Dodsons and Dotsons in early records in Virginia, Kentucky, Georgia, North Carolina, Tennessee and other states.

In early Maryland records, there were Dodsons along the Chesapeake Bay counties of Charles, Calvert and Anne Arundel, but those who migrated later into northern Ohio were Dotsons.

In one Dotson family, the father, son and grandson in the late 1700s and early 1800s are recorded as Dotsons. However, by the time the grandson migrated to Missouri and then on to Oregon, he and all his future descendants used the spelling of Dodson. There are other examples of living people sharing the same distant ancestor, with one bearing the surname of Dodson while the other is a Dotson.

Male DNA testing accurately reflects direct lineage from son to father, grandfather, great grandfather and back through many male generations. The number of matches with other males can show the generational distance of a common ancestor and help sort family lines with common surnames. As the results match with other men tested, one may be able to trace to a shared or "most common recent ancestor".

DNA test results can also prove that common names and locations do not always mean relationships. For example, a Richard Dotson was born in 1752 in Frederick County, Virginia. At the time there was a John Dodson family living less than 50 miles away. With names and locations, it was thought there were probably family connections. DNA results showed there was no relationship between these families, with Richard connected to a Chester County,Pennsylvania Dodson line, and John Dodson to a Richmond County, Virginia line. Later, one more Dotson family showed up in the same area, but again DNA tests showed that the new family was neither related to the Richard Dotson line nor to the John Dodson family. Before DNA tests, the assumption was that families were most likely connected if they shared names and lived in the same locations.

While helping to answer some questions, male Dodson-Dotson DNA testing has produced a new mystery. While several men from a Dodson-Dotson line show matches with other Dodson-Dotson males from their common line, they also share matches with several men who descend from a North Carolina Denson line. The most distant ancestor of the Dodson-Dotson males has been documented back to a Dodson line in Pennsylvania, while the ancestor of the Denson males has not yet been documented to that same generation. 

So, the question remains, were the Densons. Dodsons - or were the Dodsons, Densons? Neither line has shown any interest in changing their surname.

When researching your lineage, be sure to check under all possible spellings. And if you come across a new name, do not be surprised.

Friday, August 7, 2020

Common Problems in Researching Early Ancestors

 Problems we all Face in Research

 1. In the past, ladies of the DAR (Daughters of the American Revolution) and gentlemen of the SAR (Sons of the American Revolution) were diligent, often way too diligent, about trying to match themselves up with a Revolutionary War ancestor, a necessary requirement to become a member. In many cases, there are two or three different lineages all claiming the SAME Revolutionary War ancestor.


2. A Name and a Location do not establish a relationship. In the 1700's you can find very common English given names such as Thomas, John, William, Richard, Samuel, Michael, Charles etc. and those names were repeated into the following generations. So to assume one Thomas is the SAME Thomas found later, is a stretch, without documentation. Another common practice is to assume if a person is found in one generation with a name, such as Michael, that the next generation Michael belongs to the same line. Maybe yes and maybe no. There were certain patterns that SOME people followed such as naming children for the grandfather, uncle etc. but this wasn't always true. Sometimes the children of with a certain name died, and someone by that name might be a cousin born about the same time. There are cases of re-naming a later child for a prior deceased child. So names do not establish relationships, and since families traveled together - uncles, cousins, fathers, sons and in-laws, there's usually not enough information to make a compelling case with an isolated name and location. 

3. There was no federal census report until 1790. The Maryland and Pennsylvania lists exist for that year, but the Virginia ones do not. The 1790 census only names the head of the household, and for males, only shows those over and under age 16. Not much help in identifying people, although the location can help IF there is other information about that person in the same location, and hopefully there was only one person with that name. No names of other household members are listed until the 1850 census. So from 1790 until 1850 we only have the head of the household named, and the age range. In 1800 for example, the head of household is usually the person listed as age 26 to 45 or 'over 45', so the over 45 could be born 1755 or much earlier, and the 26 to 45 person could have been born from 1755 to 1774 - not an exact science, allowing for a lot of guessing.


4. Tax lists can be helpful, particularly if there are several years available. If a person appears in tax lists and the census, that's usually an indication of settlement in an area. Of course many tax lists are missing. The ideal list is one found in Pennsylvania in 1814 that shows name, age, occupation, but that is rare. Usually, the lists will show the county, township, whether the person owns horses, cattle and other livestock and sometimes if the person owns land. Again with duplication of names, it's hard to decide if there were two different Johns over time, such as a father and then a son, or the same John.


5. Fortunately, there were people who were dedicated to research from documents before the Internet. The Internet is a blessing and a curse. Footnote has original documents scanned, particularly the Revolutionary War pension applications, muster rolls, etc. Ancestry has the census reports and more and more books with listings. So, those 2 sources of copies of original documents are helpful in research, but both require paid membership to search.  Google Books has many old history books on line, but consider if there is documentation included or if they are just family histories.


6. LDS records, Ancestry family trees, and trees posted on the Internet have produced many half-truths and misconceptions. Some records are partly true, or true to a point, but then people have stretched a name or an event based on a theory or a guess. I have no problems with theories, just don't post them on the Internet - or- be sure to state that it's unproven or there is no documentation. We have a case of one of our long deceased cousins who posted some information on the internet a long time ago. Some of it is wrong, but he's gone, so no one can change his posting. That's the type of problem the Internet produces for us.

A convincing lineage cannot be built with 'research' that is undocumented.

Serious Genealogical Research and AI - Are they Compatible? I remember being skeptical when DNA first became popular as a genealogical tool,...