Showing posts with label Saving and Sharing Trees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Saving and Sharing Trees. Show all posts

Friday, February 18, 2022

Does it Sound too Good to be True?

 How Online Trees can Lead Us Astray


I have an ancestor believed to have been born around 1666 in England who supposedly was born on shipboard coming to America.  What we can document is a marriage of a person with her named on 14 Feb 1718 at the First Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia.  She is marrying a person believed to be my ancestor.  Male DNA shows my line connected to her husband, but we are still missing a generation, so it is still possible that my ancestor could have been a brother to her husband.  


However, over the years, people have stretched her ancestry backwards and forward with lots of undocumented information.  For example, I have seen trees with her parents listed.  Some trees show her mother as a Day; others show her as a Gray.  When I checked the documentation for the Gray name, it was based on a marriage that occurred about 100 years after my ancestor was born.  


I thought I might have a clue when I saw a photo of a gravestone on one tree.  When I enlarged the photo I saw what it said, posted below.  Then when I went to Find-a-Grave, this was a different Day family, buried in Connecticut, with that person born in Massachusetts and marrying a different person.


Ancestry makes it very easy to absorb photos and records into your trees.  This can be positive or negative - but always check the information and it there are any red flags, save the information for further research or simply ignore. 

If the information sounds too good to be true, it probably is.



Saturday, August 7, 2021

 To Share or Not to Share?


On 3 Aug 2021, Ancestry updated their Terms of Service , and some folks are very upset about what this might mean.  In fact some are recommending that you no longer upload files AND that you delete your information.


Ancestry has always had a note in the Gallery Section (where your photos, images and stories are added) which says, "All content submissions are subject to the Content Submission Agreement, which you have previously accepted."


There is a link there as well as other places on the site with statements about the responsibilities of both you and of Ancestry. The agreement has statements such as "The decision to upload personal information to the Ancestry website is your responsibility. Once you upload, the uploaded data becomes accessible by all persons accessing Ancestry websites, at least to the degree that it will be searched for data matches. Ancestry's liability and obligation in connection with the publishing of any information by you is strictly limited by the Site Terms and Conditions.. . . In addition please be aware that You agree to provide true, accurate and complete information. If any information you provide is, in our sole judgment, false or misleading, we reserve the right to terminate your use of Ancestry and/or delete all content that you have submitted."


I'm sure we have all noticed that many people have "violated" this contract by posting incorrect information or snagging and reposting information as if it is their own on Ancestry and on other public and private genealogy sites.


There are always risks in putting ANY information on the Internet whether a site is private or public. We always lose control unless we own the site. I can tell you lots of stories with bad endings when I have shared information, but I will continue to share my genealogy since I don't want it to "die" with me. I also remind myself that I might have custody of information, but I don't OWN my ancestors' stories or photographs. I've been blessed to have custody of some older photos saved by my grandparents or my parents, but the owners are deceased. Most of the photos I "own" are people who are living, not my ancestors.


So, use your own best judgement about how, when and where you choose to share your photos, stories and information, but if you are worried about who "owns" your information, do not post it on the Internet at all.

Monday, August 10, 2020

GEDCOMS and How to Use

 What is a GEDCOM and How is it Used?


GEDCOM is an acronym for Genealogical Data Communication and is a means to exchange genealogical data between different types of genealogy software programs. On-line genealogical sites and off-line genealogy programs allow for uploading or downloading files in a GEDCOM format.

If you download a GEDCOM file from the Internet or receive one from another researcher, you  must have a software program installed on your computer in order to open the file.  

There are free genealogy programs offered by Legacy, My Heritage and others, as well as programs that can be purchased.  Simply type "download free genealogy programs" and several will come up.

Here is a screenshot of free ones from Legacy and  from My Heritage, for example.


Once you have a program installed, opening a GEDCOM file is simple. If you have a program, just double-click on the GEDCOM file, and it should open with your genealogy software. Or go to your program and click on import, search for the file which should have an extension of .ged

Recently someone said she was thinking of giving up her Ancestry account.   At almost $200 per year, Ancestry is an expensive place to store one's tree, if you are not actively searching for data and documents for your ancestors.  

You can, at any time, download a GEDCOM file from Ancestry of your family tree.  Unfortunately, it will not include photos and documents, and all sources you got from Ancestry will show Ancestry as the source.  But it is far better than allowing your information to be lost.  

I made a simple diagram, below, to illustrate the steps to access the screen to download the GEDCOM.


Serious Genealogical Research and AI - Are they Compatible? I remember being skeptical when DNA first became popular as a genealogical tool,...